Birthday Cake for a Horse 4 cups sweet feed or oats 1 cup molasses or honey 2 carrots, cut into carrot sticks 1 apple, cut into slices Mix the honey and sweet feed or oats together in a large bowl. When fully mixed, place the mixture on a plate and shape into the form of a birthday cake. Use the carrots as candles and the apple slices as decorations. Horses enjoy this sticky delicious treat.