Natural Common Wart Removers Remover #1 Apply vitamin E directly to the wart, and cover it with a bandage. Repeat twice daily and eventually, the wart will disappear. It can take from a week to several months to work. Remover #2 Put a crushed garlic clove directly on the wart and cover it with a bandage. When blisters have formed after about twenty-four hours, remove the bandage. The wart should fall off within a week.