Bob Evans Nutter Butter Pie Posted by CookinMom - May 4, 2001 Source: Posted by Bob Evans Gal Monday, 29 May 2000, at 1:34 p.m. 1/2 gallon chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream Nutter Butter Cookies Chocolate cookie pie shell Magic Shell topping Scoop ice cream into pie shell, squirt on magic shell and garnish with cookies! Easy...keep frozen, of course. Makes 1 pie.